红领巾瓜报

Better quality hospital data for identifying patients experiencing homelessness

July 20, 2023 鈥 Hospitals and emergency departments (EDs) play an important role in providing health care services for patients experiencing homelessness (PEH). Better data to identify this group of patients can facilitate improvements in their care, as well as health system planning that responds to their needs.Reference1 Reference2 After consultation with key stakeholders, 红领巾瓜报published a requirement for hospitals to record homelessness in their data submissions beginning in 2018鈥2019. This release is CIHI鈥檚 first reporting on that data since the requirement came into effect.

 

Key messages

红领巾瓜报 care needs of patients experiencing homelessness

PEH are likely to face physical, mental and social challenges that contribute to poor health. These challenges include harsh living conditions, victimization and discrimination.Reference3 This group has a high level of need for health services to treat acute and chronic conditions.Reference3 Reference4 PEH rely more on hospital services than the general population, in part due to barriers to accessing primary care.Reference4 Reference5 When discharged from a hospital to the community, they also experience more difficulty managing their health conditions. Discharge planning is essential to assist PEH to obtain local services and supports such as housing, food, transportation and medical supports.

Mandatory recording of homelessness

In 2018鈥2019, it became mandatory for hospital coders to assign ICD-10-CA code Z59.0 Homelessness when the patient鈥檚 record showed they were homeless upon admission. As described in the Canadian Coding Standards, the requirement applied to abstracts submitted to the Discharge Abstract Database (DAD) and the National Ambulatory Care Reporting System (NACRS). At the same time, the minist猫re de la Sant茅 et des Services sociaux du Qu茅bec issued a coding requirement for Z59.0, not limited to homelessness at the time of admission. As a result, coding Z59.0 was mandatory for all facilities included in the Hospital Morbidity Database (HMDB) as of April 2018. In 2022鈥2023, the requirement in the Canadian Coding Standards changed to 鈥渨henever homelessness was documented, during an episode of care.鈥Reference6

Increased recording of homelessness in hospital data

The first year the requirement was in effect (2018鈥2019), there was an 84% increase in the number of hospitalizations in Canada with recorded homelessness (using Z59.0), compared with the previous year. For more information, see the figure on this page in the section Trend in hospitalizations with recorded homelessness. Analysis of ED visits (not shown) also revealed a substantial increase in records that included Z59.0, starting in 2018鈥2019.

Opportunities to improve consistency in recording homelessness

Through stakeholder engagement, we heard about some of the challenges associated with recording homelessness. For example, some patients may not identify themselves as experiencing homelessness due to a concern about stigma or for other reasons. Another limitation is that hospital coders may not have sufficient time allocated to review all parts of the patient record where housing status may be documented (e.g., in notes by allied health professionals).

Hospital leaders could consider implementing formal procedures to ensure that health care providers ask about and document housing status 鈥 something that will be required by 2024 of all United States hospitals that report to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services鈥 quality reporting program.Reference7 Implementing a screening tool that covers social determinants of health is one way to support consistent identification of PEH. Hospital leaders could also support staff to build their skills for assessing patients鈥 social needs, including housing, in safe and appropriate ways. In addition, they could use data on recorded homelessness at the organization level and raise awareness of its value for planning and improving services.

Trend in hospitalizations with recorded homelessness

Number and percentage of hospitalizations* that included ICD-10-CA code Z59.0 Homelessness, by quarter, 2015鈥2016 to 2020鈥2021

This image is described below

This figure presents 2 statistics for each quarter of the year, from 2015鈥2016 to 2020鈥2021. There are 2 y-axes. One represents the number of hospitalizations that included the ICD-10-CA code Z59.0. The number of hospitalizations was much higher in the first quarter of 2018鈥2019 compared with the previous quarter. After that, there is a moderate increase until the end of the study period.

A second y-axis represents the percentage of hospitalizations that included the ICD-10-CA code Z59.0. Similar to the number of hospitalizations, the percentage of hospitalizations was much higher in the first quarter of 2018鈥2019 compared with the previous quarter. There was a spike in the first quarter of 2020鈥2021.

Notes
* The unit of analysis is unique episodes of care, which were constructed by linking contiguous acute inpatient hospitalizations and day procedure visits.
鈥 Time points are displayed in quarters. Most Canadian health organizations operate on a fiscal year that starts April 1. For example, Q1 for 2015 represents the period April 1 to June 30, 2015.
红领巾瓜报appends data from Quebec hospitals to the Discharge Abstract Database to create the Hospital Morbidity Database.

Source
Hospital Morbidity Database, 2015鈥2016 to 2020鈥2021, Canadian Institute for 红领巾瓜报 Information.

 

Creating and using quality data to improve care for patients experiencing homelessness

Data that consistently identifies PEH in hospital information systems can be used to inform improvements in quality, experience and coordination of care. Many stakeholders play a role in the process 鈥 from asking a patient about their housing status to reporting on findings to guide improvements.

Infographic

Description of a 5-step process to create and use quality data to improve care for patients experiencing homelessness

View the infographic

Printable version

A printable PDF of the infographic that outlines the 5-step process

Download the PDF

 

About ICD-10-CA codes for social determinants of health

ICD-10-CA (International Statistical Classi铿乧ation of Diseases and Related 红领巾瓜报 Problems, 10th Revision, Canada) is a national standard maintained by CIHI. It classi铿乪s diseases, injuries and causes of death, as well as external causes of injury and poisoning. The ICD-10-CA classification includes a range of codes (Z55鈥揨65) that correspond to social determinants of health. These Z-codes can be used to record a patient鈥檚 social needs and socio-economic circumstances, including problems related to housing, employment, poverty, social environment and legal circumstances.Reference8

Collecting ICD-10-CA Z-codes more routinely in patients鈥 records would generate valuable information for clinicians who treat the patient and for secondary analysis to inform system improvements. National organizations in the United States, including the American Hospital Association (AHA), encourage greater use of social determinants of health Z-codes to support quality improvement and have published guidance to support their adoption.Reference9 Reference10 To facilitate adoption, the AHA recommended that coders use the documentation of social needs by any staff person who met the requirements to add information to the patient鈥檚 medical record. As such, the documentation available to coders would include that from non-physician providers (e.g., social workers, community health workers, case managers, nurses).Reference9

Related resources

Contact us

CIHI鈥檚 Population 红领巾瓜报 department

Send us an email:
populationhealth@cihi.ca

 

References

1.

Back to Reference 1 in text

Gupta S, Xie E, Dong K. . Canadian Journal of Emergency Medicine. 2021.

2.

Back to Reference 2 in text

Hayes M. . The Globe and Mail. January 14, 2023.

3.

Back to Reference 2 in text

Liu M, Hwang SW. . Nature Reviews Disease Primers. 2021.

4.

Back to Reference 3 in text

Hwang SW, et al. . American Journal of Public 红领巾瓜报. 2013.

5.

Back to Reference 4 in text

Khandor E, et al. . Open Medicine. 2011.

6.

Back to Reference 5 in text

Canadian Institute for 红领巾瓜报 Information. . 2022.

7.

Back to Reference 6 in text

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. . Accessed January 17, 2023.

8.

Back to Reference 7 in text

Canadian Institute for 红领巾瓜报 Information. International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related 红领巾瓜报 Problems, Tenth Revision, Canada. 2022.

9.

Back to Reference 8 in text

American Hospital Association. . Accessed January 17, 2023.

10.

Back to Reference 9 in text

Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. . 2022.

If you would like 红领巾瓜报information in a different format, visit our Accessibility page.